Saturday I was scheduled three shifts in a row at work: an 8 am classroom session, a 12 pm lunch shift, and a 5:15 pm dinner shift. Sheesh. I did have nsome spare time between class and lunch, so I rushed by Wal-mart and Target, sped to the post office, and stopped back by my house before returning to the restaurant. As I drove, I listened to a sociologist, working woman, and NPR commentator discussing living at the poverty line in America.
At first, I heard the woman say something which I thought was a sound clip, since the two men began to discuss her words and her situation. Realizing that she was actually there with them in the studio gave me a rather violent turn, since the men kept talking as if she weren't there at all. How much she must have felt like an objcet, a case, a study! The conversation began to focus upon the details of this woman's life: her large family, her status as sole bread-winner, how hard it was to keep insurance, how hard it was to keep cars running, etceteras. I would have been quite embarrassed.
What really got to me, though, was the fact that towards the end of the interview, they asked this woman what she had to do without. The reply was mild-mannered and summery: "Well, we go without sometime, sometime. But we're fine. The kids are in school aren't they? Things ain't so bad."
The sociologist INTERRUPTED her to tell us that this was just her being too proud to share the details, which he proceeded to do. He and the commentator then commenced to try to convince this noble woman that she was doing something hard and difficult and had every right to take it out on the establishment ("the establishment" being our last two presidents, Bush and Clinton)! What?!
I was mad. I was ready to call up my local NPR affiliate and let them have it. But then this lady replies, again just as breezy and warm and mild as an early summer's day, only this time her words are tinged with some sorrow, as if the corners of her eyes have gone moist: "Oh, you're sweet. You're really sweet. The only thing is, is -- you've got too high expectations. You just talkin about things because that's the way you was raised. A body don't need all that much. Somebody like me just needs to know that things are gonna be better, maybe better for her children. That's all I need right now."
Expectations, huh? Well shoot. Shoot, shoot, shoot. The men seemed to sit back, somewhat abashed, quickly making obligatory thank yous and giving a plug for the sociologist's new book about this woman and low-class America. I turned off the radio and began to hum a little.
Posted by nickles at December 6, 2004 09:41 AMI'm reminded of the book where a well-educated woman decided to go take blue-collar jobs for a few months, and wrote about her findings. She decried the conditions of working-class America, saying it was impossible to get by. Then it was pointed out that she didn't need to eat fast food all the time, didn't need to stay in motel rooms, and didn't need to drive nearly as much as she did. Expectations again.
Posted by: ryan at December 6, 2004 12:53 PMHey, I taught "Before the Law" by Kafka today. Go read it and think about it and see if it sheds any light on this issue of expectations and perceptions.
Posted by: Krista at December 8, 2004 03:42 PMI don't have it! Maybe I can find it. I'm ashamed to say that all my anthologies are either British or American. Well, not really ashamed. Just surprised and annoyed.
Thanks for the tip. I'll let you know if and when I read it. :)
Posted by: bob at December 11, 2004 12:44 AMIt's in the Prentice Hall Literature textbook, Platinum Level.
It seems to have a lot of random and obscure literature in it. I taught a poem the other day that none of the Covenant English profs had heard of...or at least they didn't have time to email me about. The Bridegroom by Pushkin.
Posted by: Krista at December 11, 2004 06:21 PMSpeaking of which, how can you tell if a textbook is a good one? What makes the ones you use good or bad?
Posted by: bob at December 12, 2004 11:02 PMI'll write you an email airing my opinion of that and you can post it someday. It will probably be more valid if you ask someone with a scosh (spelling?) more experience than I have.
Posted by: Krista at December 13, 2004 03:51 PM